• UK
  • World
    • USA
  • Entertainment
    • Celeb
    • Showbiz
    • Magazine
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Tech
  • Science
    • Education
  • Insurance
  • Business
  • Auto
  • ToS/Contact
    • ToS
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
NewsExplored
  • UK
  • World
    • USA
  • Entertainment
    • Celeb
    • Showbiz
    • Magazine
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Tech
  • Science
    • Education
  • Insurance
  • Business
  • Auto
  • ToS/Contact
    • ToS
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • LinkedIn

  • Tumblr

  • RSS

USA

Breonna Taylor: Why it’s hard to charge US police over shootings

Breonna Taylor: Why it’s hard to charge US police over shootings
Newsexplored
25th September 2020
6
SHARES
ShareTweet
SubscribeRedditGoogleWhatsappStumbleuponPinterestDiggLinkedinTumblrTelegram
Views:
1
Protester holds picture of Breonna TaylorImage copyright Getty Images

Three officers were involved in the police raid that ended with Breonna Taylor shot dead in her home in Kentucky. Only one of them has been charged, but not in relation to her death. Why are so few police officers charged after fatal shootings in the US?

Brett Hankison faces three counts of “wanton endangerment” for firing into an adjacent apartment, putting Ms Taylor’s neighbours at risk.

The other two officers involved were not charged - despite one of them firing the fatal shot - because Ms Taylor’s boyfriend fired first, mistaking them for intruders.

It’s a decision that has sparked some bewilderment and prompted hundreds to take to the streets of Louisville and elsewhere. But it’s not the first time a fatal shooting by a police officer has made headlines but not made it to trial. The ones that do are a tiny fraction.

In 2020 so far there have been 10 officers charged, according to Dr Phil Stinson, a professor at Bowling Green State University in Ohio and a former police officer, who has been collecting data on police prosecutions since 2005.

The year with the most officers charged was 2015, when 18 law enforcement members faced murder or manslaughter charges.

The Washington Post estimates police shoot and kill about 1,000 people each year in the US. Most of those incidents do not rise to the level of controversy or scrutiny seen in Ms Taylor’s case, and may have occurred when the officers were themselves fired upon.

  • How often are US police killed on duty?
  • What happened to Breonna Taylor?

But getting a charge or conviction for those tragedies that involve excessive use of police force is rare.

These are the factors that explain why.

The law over reasonable force

Although the language of laws that dictate what police may do vary from state to state, the most common standard officers have to abide by is that their use of force be “objectively reasonable”.

That means the officer had a reasonable belief in the moment that he or she, or a bystander, were about to be harmed.

data-ad-format="auto">

That standard has come under increased scrutiny for giving police too much leeway, particularly the flexibility of the word “reasonable” - it could be enough that an officer believed they were in danger at the time, even if hindsight showed they were not.

“In these cases, historically, the police have owned the narratives. Bystander accounts are discounted, oftentimes,” says Dr Stinson.”Written reports are sometimes factually inconsistent with the video evidence.”

California changed its use of force law in August, swapping out the word “reasonable” for the word “necessary”. It’s probably one of the strictest laws in the country.

Local prosecutors also have nearly unlimited discretion on whether or not to bring charges against officers, and won’t if they deem the shooting justified.


Some jurisdictions use a grand jury to make the determination on whether to charge, but these proceedings are secret.

Prosecutors work closely with police in their day-to-day caseload, which Kate Levine, an associate professor at the Benjamin N Cardozo School of Law, says could lead to more favourable treatment.

Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption The death of Freddie Gray from injuries suffered in a police van led to protests and riots in Baltimore in 2015

It could also be easier not to bring charges, she adds, if there are doubts they can prove a case.

“You want to think about it more cynically, it’s very easy to say you can’t prove a case when you don’t want to.”

Trust in police

Judges and juries may also have trusting feelings towards police, and be less likely to doubt their word, says Ms Levine.

“Part of their job is, in theory, putting themselves in dangerous situations with people who can cause harm to them or others.

“Social norms dictate that people tend to believe the police when they say they were in fear for their life. So it’s hard to make a case that they weren’t without evidence to the contrary.”

The unions

Police unions are some of the strongest in the country, and over time some have written into officers’ contracts various conditions that can slow the investigative process after a killing, such as giving the officer advance warning about an impending investigation.

The former police chief of Philadelphia, Charles Ramsey, openly complained that he could not fire officers who’d committed crimes because of the city’s union-negotiated arbitration system.

Officers also benefit from qualified immunity, which means they can’t be personally or monetarily held responsible in civil lawsuits. The thinking goes that with these kinds of protections, officers have little to fear of consequences for their actions.

Some cases where police charged:

  • Four officers in case of George Floyd, who was killed in May
  • Two officers in case of Rayshard Brooks, shot dead a few weeks later
  • Jason Van Dyke jailed over fatal shooting of teenager Laquan McDonald in 2014
  • Michael Slager jailed for shooting Derek Scott in the back in 2015

Cases where US police have faced charges

But Stinson cautions that police unions give the majority of officers important rights.

“The collective bargaining agreements provide due process protections more than anything else,” he says. “And police officers don’t shed their constitutional rights when they walk into a police station each morning.”

Systemic changes

Some have cautioned that putting all the focus on charges and prison time for police officers who kill civilians gives a false sense that policing in the US is truly changing.

Ms Levine says looking at the procedures used by the officers in Ms Taylor’s case is more important to lasting reform.

“We are really spending too much time focusing on prosecution and incarceration of individual police officers,” she says, “and not enough time on big systemic changes that will stop police officers from being at Breonna Taylor’s house in the early hours of the morning with a battering ram.”.

Follow Jessica on Twitter @Lussenpop

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Share on Skype (Opens in new window)

Related

Related Itemsbreonnachargepoliceshootingstaylor
USA
25th September 2020
Newsexplored @newsexploredweb

Related Itemsbreonnachargepoliceshootingstaylor

More in USA

  • Read More
    Ethiopia River Nile dam: PM condemns ‘aggressions’ after Trump comment

    Views:1 image copyrightReuters image captionThe dam will be the biggest hydro-electric project in Africa Ethiopia’s prime minister...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • US Election 2020: Biden seeks to clarify remark on ending oil

    Views:1 Related Topics US election 2020 media captionWhat you missed - the best bits from Trump and Biden’s final debate US President Donald Trump has seized on a TV debate remark by his White House rival Joe Biden about shutting down the oil industry, as the Democrat scrambled to clear up the...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    Presidential debate: Trump and Biden row over Covid, climate and racism

    Views:1 Related Topics media captionWhat you missed - the best bits from Trump and Biden’s final debate...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    Fact-check: Who caged children first?

    Views:1 By Reality Check teamBBC News Related Topics image copyrightReuters President Trump and his Democratic rival Joe...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    Breonna Taylor: Officer in shooting says it ‘was not a race thing’

    Views:1 Published 51 minutes ago Related Topics image copyrightFacebook image captionBreonna Taylor, 26, was a decorated emergency...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    The Countdown: Tiffany Trump trends and two rivals show love

    Views:1 Related Topics US election 2020 With 14 days to go, Mr Trump heads to Pennsylvania for...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    US election 2020: Trump and Biden feud over debate topics

    Views:1 Related Topics US election 2020 media captionWho really decides the US election? US President Donald Trump...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    US election 2020: Fact-checking Trump and Biden town hall events

    Views:1 By Reality Check teamBBC News Related Topics image copyrightReuters image captionMr Trump took part in an...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    Amy Coney Barrett: Trump US Supreme Court pick grilled on presidential powers

    Views:1 image copyrightGetty Images image captionAmy Coney Barrett takes questions from Senators for a final day President...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    US election: Biden says Florida seniors ‘expendable’ for Trump

    Views:1 Published 2 hours ago Related Topics image copyrightReuters image captionJoe Biden said the only senior Donald...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    Twitter suspends accounts claiming to be black Trump supporters

    Views:1 Image copyright Reuters Image caption Donald Trump is campaigning for the 3 November election Twitter has...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
  • Read More
    US election 2020: World reaction to long queues of voters in US

    Views:1 Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Some Texas voters got up early and still faced long...

    Newsexplored 25th September 2020
Scroll for more
Tap
data-ad-format="auto">
NewsExplored

NewsExplored - Making sure all the latest news is explored?

Contact us for help

  • Popular

  • Latest

  • Comments

  • Ervin Staub: A Holocaust survivor’s mission to train ‘heroic bystanders’
    USA5th October 2020
  • Storm Alex brings heavy rain and high winds to parts of UK
    UK2nd October 2020
  • Hull to Belgium ferry closure ‘end of an era’ for city
    UK1st October 2020
  • Transfer news: Winners and losers after deadline day
    Sports6th October 2020
  • Ethiopia River Nile dam: PM condemns ‘aggressions’ after Trump comment
    USA24th October 2020
  • US Election 2020: Biden seeks to clarify remark on ending oil
    USA24th October 2020
  • Presidential debate: Trump and Biden row over Covid, climate and racism
    USA23rd October 2020
  • Fact-check: Who caged children first?
    USA23rd October 2020
  • Les Rehrer says:

    Hello Its me :P and thanks for this post

  • optumrx login says:

    Thank For News.

  • Kent Laatsch says:

    Please let me know if you're looking for a writer…

  • Bob says:

    RT News was where I learned that Erdogan controlled isis.…

Copyright © 2018 Top News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by Wordpress.

Breonna Taylor: Family lawyer slams ‘devilish’ grand jury outcome
FBI probes police killing of boy on family’s drive
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok