• UK
  • World
    • USA
  • Entertainment
    • Celeb
    • Showbiz
    • Magazine
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Tech
  • Science
    • Education
  • Insurance
  • Business
  • Auto
  • ToS/Contact
    • ToS
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
NewsExplored
  • UK
  • World
    • USA
  • Entertainment
    • Celeb
    • Showbiz
    • Magazine
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • Gaming
  • Tech
  • Science
    • Education
  • Insurance
  • Business
  • Auto
  • ToS/Contact
    • ToS
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • LinkedIn

  • Tumblr

  • RSS

Politics

What next for the Holyrood inquiry if Salmond does not appear?

What next for the Holyrood inquiry if Salmond does not appear?
Newsexplored
9th February 2021
6
SHARES
ShareTweet
SubscribeRedditGoogleWhatsappStumbleuponPinterestDiggLinkedinTumblrTelegram
Views:
0

By Philip Sim
BBC Scotland News

image captionThe inquiry committee has been moving between virtual and in-person meetings during the pandemic

MSPs investigating the Scottish government’s botched handling of complaints against Alex Salmond had planned a pivotal session with the former first minister. However, they have been left with more questions than ever after the meeting was called off.

With only weeks left for the committee to take evidence, and the attendance of a key witness hanging in the balance, where does this leave the inquiry?

What’s happening?

Alex Salmond had been widely expected to attend a meeting on Tuesday of a Holyrood inquiry into the government’s mishandling of sexual harassment complaints against him.

The session was expected to see the escalating row between Mr Salmond and his successor in Bute House, Nicola Sturgeon, enter its endgame.

However, the meeting was called off as the latest development in a long-running dispute between the former first minster and the committee over what evidence could be produced and published.

data-ad-format="auto">

There is little time left for Mr Salmond to give evidence, with MSPs rushing to complete their hearings and compile a report before Holyrood breaks up in March ahead of the coming election.

With Ms Sturgeon pencilled in as the closing witness on 16 February, there are literally days left to find an agreement if the former SNP leader is to appear,

image captionAlex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon are the final witnesses to appear before the Holyrood inquiry

What next for the committee?

MSPs will be comforted by the fact the most important witness of all – Ms Sturgeon – is still on track to attend, and indeed says she is looking forward to putting her side of the story.

What remains to be seen is whether they can get Mr Salmond in before then too.

The core issue appears to be whether the committee publishes a submission he made which alleges – in detail – that Ms Sturgeon broke the ministerial code.

He says he cannot live up to an oath to “tell the whole truth” without being able to refer to this document, and that the group cannot make a full report without taking it into consideration.

The decision is not entirely down to the nine MSPs on the committee – it is also a question for Holyrood’s cross-party management board, the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, and its team of in-house lawyers.

As it stands they are sticking to their guns and saying the submission cannot be published. There are parts they could not countenance publishing themselves, and given it has leaked out in full elsewhere online they feel they cannot even offer a redacted version.

They say Mr Salmond could “speak freely in committee about all of his contact with Nicola Sturgeon and his views on her actions” and that much of the paper could still be referred to.

However, Mr Salmond’s lawyers say this is not good enough. And they have lined up a series of other asks, including “very specific direction” on every matter which he would not be allowed to speak to due to court orders – a bar which seems unlikely to be met in the short time remaining.

image captionMr Salmond was acquitted of charges of sexual assault following a trial in March 2020

What might Alex Salmond do instead?

There have been suggestions that Mr Salmond might hold a news conference of some kind instead of appearing at Holyrood.

He has, after all, been waiting almost a year to have his say. He walked free from the High Court last March on the very day the Covid-19 lockdown was imposed, saying there was “certain evidence” he wanted to come to light – but noting that it would have to wait.

A press conference would give Mr Salmond greater control over a number of key matters. These include the timing – he could have his say after Nicola Sturgeon’s evidence session, and thus the “last word” – and crucially the content, being bound only by the advice of his own lawyers rather than those of the parliament.

He also would not be facing questions from a panel of his political rivals, a grilling under oath about a sensitive subject – but instead sparring with the press, something he rather enjoyed as first minister.

However, while such a session would attract plenty of attention, it would not have the same gravitas as a Holyrood appearance. Any allegations he levelled might not have the same legitimacy coming from behind a home-made podium as they would in a parliamentary setting.

What he opts to do may depend on what Mr Salmond’s ultimate goal is. If he just wants to state his own position, a press conference may suit. But if he is looking for some greater outcome – ranging from heads rolling at an official level to the potential downfall of Ms Sturgeon herself – then he may judge he has a better chance from inside the inquiry room.

image captionIt has been suggested that Alex Salmond may look to hold a press conference instead of attending at Holyrood

What will opposition MSPs do?

There has been much disquiet from opposition members in particular about the way the inquiry has played out – and how it keeps running into walls.

Beyond the cooperation of key players, there are elements of the overall probe which are inextricably tied up with the High Court trial which saw Mr Salmond acquitted of charges of sexual assault – and which cannot be referred to without risking the anonymity of the complainers.

Lib Dem MSP Alex Cole-Hamilton has said the committee is “in crisis”, and there have been reports that other members may consider resigning in protest.

To start with, this may be unlikely before Ms Sturgeon gives evidence. Members will not want to forfeit the chance to quiz the first minister.

But after that, they face the prospect of trying to hash out a report, despite partisan divisions over what it should say and potentially only a partial set of evidence to draw from.

It may be that some members calculate that they could make a bigger splash by simply blowing the whole thing up and walking away from the committee – but this would be very much a last resort.

What does it mean for Nicola Sturgeon?

The drama over Mr Salmond’s appearance is in a way simply a distraction for Ms Sturgeon – firstly from the Covid-19 pandemic, but also from her own upcoming witness session.

Whether her predecessor shows up will not change the substance of what the FM needs to do, which is to conclusively settle the questions over what she knew and when.

Of course, the committee may not have the final word on that matter. The more significant investigation may well be that of James Hamilton, the independent advisor on the ministerial code.

image captionCommittee members are unlikely to want to give up the chance to question Nicola Sturgeon

While the committee’s remit is primarily about failings in government procedures and their application, Mr Hamilton’s probe will answer a much more straightforward question, of whether or not the first minister misled parliament and broke her own code of conduct, and thus his findings may prove far more significant.

Mr Salmond may have already concluded this – his controversial submission was originally made to Mr Hamilton – and he may be placing less emphasis on the committee because of it.

However, this is not something Ms Sturgeon can afford to do. As first minister she will have to answer to both investigations, and there will be intense scrutiny on her witness session whenever it eventually comes.

When the history of the Holyrood inquiry is written, it might be concluded that it was boxed in from the very outset by its remit and by court orders, and the necessity that it not cut across or re-run any of the criminal proceedings.

That said, it could still play a pivotal role in the future of the current first minister.

Related Topics

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Share on Skype (Opens in new window)

Related

Related Itemsappearholyroodinquirysalmond
Politics
9th February 2021
Newsexplored @newsexploredweb

Related Itemsappearholyroodinquirysalmond

More in Politics

  • Read More
    Freeports: What are they and where will they be?

    Views:0 Published 32 minutes ago image copyrightGetty Images The locations of eight new freeports in England have...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    The seven key questions facing Nicola Sturgeon

    Views:0 By Nick EardleyBBC political correspondent image copyrightPA Media Scotland’s first minister is set to give evidence...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Vaccine passports: Do I need one for going out, work and travel?

    Views:0 By Eleanor LawrieBBC News image copyrightGetty Images Vaccine passports could soon be needed to go on...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Budget 2021: What is it and when will it happen?

    Views:0 By Kevin PeacheyBBC News Published 2 days ago image copyrightGetty Images This year’s Budget will be...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Climate change: Six questions about the Cumbria coal controversy

    Views:0 By Roger HarrabinBBC environment analyst image copyrightWest Cumbria Mining Company image captionThe mine would extract coking...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Could indyref2 be held without the UK’s consent?

    Views:0 By Philip SimBBC Scotland political reporter image copyrightGetty Images image captionThe case has been brought by...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Covid-19: NI lockdown to be extended until 5 March

    Views:0 image copyrightPacemaker Coronavirus lockdown restrictions in Northern Ireland will be extended until 5 March, the first...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Covid: What is universal credit – and what other benefits are available?

    Views:0 image copyrightGetty Images Labour and some Conservative MPs are calling on the government to keep a...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Brexit: Five surprising consequences

    Views:0 By Reality Check teamBBC News image copyrightGetty Images While the UK government had been warning of...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Covid-19: Northern Ireland’s R-rate ‘falls significantly’

    Views:0 image copyrightPA Media image captionMichelle O’Neill and Arlene Foster appeared at their first joint press conference...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Brexit: ‘Problems’ in first week of post-deal GB-NI trade

    Views:0 By Conor MacauleyBBC NI Agriculture & Environment Correspondent image copyrightReuters image captionThe first lorries to cross...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
  • Read More
    Covid-19: Stormont to give clarity on restrictions and exams

    Views:0 image copyrightReuters Ministers are to explain their decision to tighten Covid-19 restrictions in Northern Ireland at...

    Newsexplored 9th February 2021
Scroll for more
Tap
data-ad-format="auto">
NewsExplored

NewsExplored - Making sure all the latest news is explored?

Contact us for help

  • Popular

  • Latest

  • Comments

  • Transfer rumours: Kounde, Haaland, Bremer, Neuhaus, Balogun, Ziyech, Raphinha
    Sports13th February 2021
  • Station reopening at Bow Street brings first trains for 56 years
    UK14th February 2021
  • Manchester United 3-3 Everton: Dominic Calvert-Lewin scores late goal to deny hosts
    Sports6th February 2021
  • Super Bowl half-time show: How did The Weeknd do?
    Entertainment8th February 2021
  • LeBron James: NBA superstar’s evolution from high school prodigy
    USA4th March 2021
  • What is Biden doing differently at US border?
    USA3rd March 2021
  • Coronavirus: Texas and other states ease rules despite warnings
    USA3rd March 2021
  • Golden Globe Awards 2021: Stars prepare for virtual ceremony
    USA28th February 2021
  • Les Rehrer says:

    Hello Its me :P and thanks for this post

  • optumrx login says:

    Thank For News.

  • Kent Laatsch says:

    Please let me know if you're looking for a writer…

  • Bob says:

    RT News was where I learned that Erdogan controlled isis.…

Copyright © 2018 Top News Theme. Theme by MVP Themes, powered by Wordpress.

Budget 2021: What is it and when will it happen?
Vaccine passports: Do I need one for going out, work and travel?
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok