However, it was in fact 27-year-old Robbie Williams tribute act Dan Budd performing the crooner's hit, No Regrets.
Dan's career as a tribute artist first became successful when Robbie, 42, tweeted a picture of himself next to a poster of one of the lookalike’s upcoming gigs, almost three years ago.
“Good grief, you look like a friend of mine,” said Gary, before adding: “I’m scared to ask what you do for a living.”
One viewer tweeted the 46-year-old singer, asking: "@GaryBarlow why is @robbiewilliams performing on #LetItShine?"
Let It Shine fans gobsmacked as ROBBIE WILLIAMS auditions for Gary Barlow series
Good grief, you look like a friend of mine.
"Just turned on let it shine… for a minute I actually thought it was @robbiewilliams," posted another.
A third said: "Mum walks in thinking I'm legit watching Robbie Williams #LetItShine."
"@garybarlow OMG Dan Budd on #LetItShine! had to look up as thought Robbie was auditioning, then I did look up and still thought the same!!!," tweeted a fourth.
Other viewers praised the tribute act, but some noted that, in an awkward twist, the contestant was singing about Take That's break up.
Let It Shine: Robbie Williams poses in front of a poster for tribute act Dan Budd
The best musical talent shows
Wed, November 16, 2016
Get Quotes on Home Insurance
As Gary Barlow launches new talent show 'Let it Shine' to find the stars of a Take That musical, we look at the successful musical theatre talent shows of the past.
1 of 7
Let it Shine – The new BBC show will see Gary Barlow looking for five young men to star in a new Take That musical
One viewer tweeted: "Can't believe the Robbie tribute on #LetItShine singing the song he wrote about take that's break up @GaryBarlow."
"Watching #LetItShine I can spot a fake @robbiewilliams a mile off but that man had it nailed," posted another.
A third joked: "That awkward moment when the Robbie Williams tribute act sounds better than actual Robbie Williams. #LetItShine."
"This dude on #LetItShine doesn't half sound like @robbiewilliams wow! Closed my eyes and thought I was listening to Robbie!! It's eerie. Every mannerism and the way he rolls his eyes is the same," posted a fourth.